If there is one thing I do not want to be doing right before Thanksgiving dinner, it is mashing five pounds of potatoes. These party potatoes solve that problem. They are creamy, buttery mashed potatoes made with cream cheese and sour cream, spread into a casserole dish and baked until the top turns golden. Best of all, you can make them up to two days ahead. That makes party potatoes the easiest make-ahead Thanksgiving side dish on my menu.
I love serving these alongside my crock pot mac and cheese and collard greens with ham hocks. Both are great for holiday gatherings, and you can find even more ideas in my comfort food favorites.
Jump to:
Party Potatoes Ingredients
A handful of simple ingredients makes these extra creamy. See the recipe card for exact amounts.
- Yukon gold potatoes - five pounds, peeled. Waxy enough to hold together, starchy enough to mash smooth.
- Cream cheese - full fat, room temperature. The structural ingredient.
- Sour cream - a full cup.
- Milk - warmed.
- Salt - two teaspoons, on top of salting the boiling water.
- Black pepper - freshly ground. Half a teaspoon, which is less than it sounds in a 9x13.
- Onion powder - not a shortcut, a choice. Fresh onion in a make-ahead casserole goes sharp and slightly metallic by day two.
- Garlic powder - same reasoning. It disperses evenly through five pounds of potato in a way minced garlic never does.
- Butter, for dotting - four tablespoons in small pieces, scattered over the top. It melts down into the surface and is half of why the crust browns.
- Paprika - on top, generously. Not primarily for flavor. Paprika catches the oven's heat and gives color to a dish that otherwise comes out pale and beige.
Why Party Potatoes Are the Best Make-Ahead Thanksgiving Side Dish
- Make-ahead friendly. Prep the casserole up to two days in advance.
- Extra creamy. Cream cheese and sour cream give the potatoes a rich, velvety texture.
- Golden on top. A little butter and paprika give the casserole a beautiful finish.
- Made for sharing. Five pounds of potatoes feeds about 10 to 12 people.
- Simple pantry seasonings. Garlic powder and onion powder add flavor without extra prep.
How to Make Party Potatoes
The trick is to drain the potatoes well and mix them only until smooth. Too much mixing can make mashed potatoes gummy.
Boil the Potatoes
Peel the potatoes and cut them into even chunks, then boil until completely soft. Drain them and add them to a large bowl with the butter and salt while they are still hot, so the butter melts straight into them.
Combine the Butter and Potatoes
Using a hand mixer or a stand mixer, combine the butter and the potatoes. Keep the speed low - you are working the butter through, not whipping the potatoes.
Add the Sour Cream and Cream Cheese
Add the sour cream and the room-temperature cream cheese. The residual heat in the potatoes is what melts the cream cheese in, which is why it goes in while everything is still hot.
Add the Milk
Pour in the warmed milk. Cold milk drops the temperature of the bowl and makes you run the mixer longer, and running the mixer longer is the one thing you are trying to avoid.
Mix Until Smooth and Fluffy
Mix with the stand mixer until the potatoes are smooth, creamy and fluffy - and then stop. This is the only unfixable mistake in the recipe. Past this point the starch granules rupture and the potatoes turn gluey, and nothing brings them back. If you are unsure, stop early.
Add the Garlic Powder and Onion Powder
Add the garlic powder and onion powder and mix just until they disappear into the potatoes. Powders rather than fresh aromatics, because fresh onion and garlic go sharp and slightly metallic in a casserole that sits for two days.
Pour Into the Casserole Dish
Pour the potato mixture into the buttered casserole dish and spread it evenly. Leave a little texture on the surface rather than smoothing it glass-flat - ridges catch the heat and brown.
Dot the Potatoes With Butter
Cut the butter into small pieces and dot them evenly over the surface. It melts down into the top as it bakes, and it is half the reason the crust browns.
Sprinkle With Paprika
Sprinkle the whole top generously with paprika until it is lightly covered all over. It is there for color more than flavor - without it the dish bakes up pale and beige.
Substitutions
A few swaps that work well:
- Yukon gold → russet. It works, but only if you are baking the same day. Russets make a fluffier mash that separates and goes watery overnight, which defeats the point of the recipe.
- Sour cream → full-fat Greek yogurt. One-for-one, slightly tangier. Do not use low-fat; it splits in the oven and leaves a layer of liquid on top.
- Milk → half-and-half or heavy cream. Richer, and fine. Warm it either way. Buttermilk works too and pushes it noticeably tangier, which I like against turkey and gravy.
- Onion and garlic powder → 4 chopped scallions and 2 cloves roasted garlic. The fresher-tasting version, and very good, but only if you are baking within twenty-four hours. Beyond that the alliums go sharp.
- Cream cheese → mascarpone. Use the same amount for a milder, slightly sweeter flavor.
- Paprika → smoked paprika. Same color, but it brings actual smoke. Use half as much; it is far more assertive.
Variations
Try one of these versions:
- Loaded. Fold in a cup of sharp cheddar and six slices of crumbled cooked bacon before it goes in the dish, and scatter scallions over after it comes out.
- Chive and parmesan. Half a cup of grated parmesan folded in, another quarter cup over the top with the paprika, and chopped chives at the end. The parmesan on top browns into something close to a crust.
- Two smaller dishes. Split it between two 8x8 pans. More browned surface per serving, both fit into oven gaps a 9x13 cannot, and you can freeze one.
Equipment
Nothing fancy needed-just a large pot, mixing bowl or mixer, and casserole dish.
- Stand mixer with the paddle attachment. The paddle folds; the whisk whips, and whipping is how you get glue. Five pounds of potatoes also needs real bowl capacity. (KitchenAid 7qt Bowl-Lift Stand Mixer / Smeg Stand Mixer)
- Large stockpot - Choose an 8-quart or larger pot so the potatoes have room to cook evenly.
- Colander. One that drains fast and lets the potatoes sit shallow enough to steam, not a sieve they pile up in. (Bellemain Colander / OXO Salad Spinner Basket)
- 9x13 casserole dish. Ceramic or stoneware browns the top evenly and holds heat on the table, which matters for a dish that sits out while people go back for seconds. (Le Creuset Stoneware 9x13 / Caraway Ceramic Baking Dish)
- Large cutting board. Peeling and chunking five pounds of potatoes needs somewhere to put them. (John Boos RA-Board Maple 20x15 / Greener Chef Luxury Bamboo XL)
Storage
Store: Assembled and unbaked, cover tightly and refrigerate up to two days - that is the whole design of the recipe. Already baked, cool to room temperature within two hours, then cover and refrigerate up to four days.
Reheat: Cover with foil and warm in a 350°F oven twenty-five to thirty minutes, then uncover for the last five to bring the top back. Splash two or three tablespoons of milk over the surface first; it tightens overnight.
Freeze: Up to two months, and unbaked freezes better than baked. Assemble in a freezer-safe dish, wrap in plastic then foil, and freeze.
Top Tip
Use room-temperature cream cheese and warm milk so they mix in easily. Once the potatoes are creamy, stop mixing. That is the easiest way to keep them light instead of gluey.
FAQ
You can assemble the casserole up to two days ahead. Cover tightly and refrigerate. When you are ready to bake, add the butter and paprika and bake uncovered for 45 to 50 minutes, until heated through.
They were probably mixed too long. Potatoes release starch as you beat them, which can turn the texture stretchy or gummy. Use the paddle on low speed-or mash by hand-and stop as soon as everything is combined.
Yes! A potato masher works well and gives a slightly more rustic texture. A hand mixer is fine on low speed, too. Avoid a food processor, which can make mashed potatoes gummy very quickly.
These are made for turkey and gravy, but they are just as good with ham, roast chicken or short ribs. I also love them with a big helping of greens.
Party Potatoes (Make-Ahead Mashed Potato Casserole)
- Total Time: 1 hour 15 minutes
- Yield: 10 to 12 servings 1x
Description
Make-ahead mashed potatoes you assemble up to two days early and bake on the day. Five pounds of Yukon golds folded with cream cheese and sour cream, spread into a 9x13, dotted with butter and dusted with paprika so the top browns. Serves 10 to 12 and frees up your stovetop entirely.
Ingredients
- 5 lb Yukon gold potatoes, peeled and cut into 2-inch chunks
- Salt, for the cooking water
- 8 oz cream cheese, room temperature
- 1 cup sour cream
- ½ cup milk, warmed
- 2 tsp salt
- ½ tsp black pepper
- 1 tsp onion powder
- 1 tsp garlic powder
- 4 tbsp butter, cut into small pieces, for dotting, plus more for the dish
- 1 tsp paprika, for the top
Instructions
- Heat the oven to 350°F. Butter a 9x13-inch casserole dish, including the corners and sides.
- Put the peeled potato chunks in a large (8-quart or larger) pot and cover with cold water by 1 inch. Salt the water well - it should taste seasoned.
- Bring to a boil over high heat, then cook 15 to 20 minutes, until a knife slides into a chunk with no resistance.
- Drain into a colander. Leave the potatoes to steam dry for 1 full minute, shaking the colander gently once, so the surface water evaporates.
- Transfer the hot potatoes to the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment. Do not use the whisk.
- Add the cream cheese, sour cream, warmed milk, 2 teaspoons salt, ½ teaspoon pepper, 1 teaspoon onion powder and 1 teaspoon garlic powder.
- Mix on the lowest speed only, until the mixture just comes together and looks uniform. Stop the mixer immediately. Potatoes mixed past this point turn gluey and cannot be fixed.
- Spread into the buttered dish in an even layer and smooth the top with the back of a spoon, leaving a little texture rather than a flat surface.
- Dot the 4 tablespoons of butter evenly over the top, then sprinkle generously with paprika until the surface is lightly covered all over.
- Bake uncovered 30 minutes, until the top is browned and the edges are bubbling. Do not cover it - foil traps steam and the top will not brown.
- TO MAKE AHEAD: stop after step 8, cover tightly with plastic wrap pressed onto the surface and refrigerate up to 2 days. On the day, dot with butter, dust with paprika and bake uncovered 45 to 50 minutes, until browned and hot through the center.
- Prep Time: 25 minutes
- Cook Time: 50 minutes
- Category: Side Dish
- Method: Baked
- Cuisine: American
Nutrition
- Serving Size: about ¾ cup






Comments
No Comments